Home Page
|
This is an analysis/safety review of an incident that happened at Moss Point '02. Names have been changed because that's not important to the lesson. Kirk VanZandt wrote the following:
The "John" Accident: I would like to point out that similar accidents have happened in the past, and most likely will occur in the future. The best thing we all can do is to learn how to avoid such incidents like this from past experience. The following is not to blame anyone or put any person at fault, it is only to clarify the events and make suggestions to what might be done to prevent future accidents. I have talked or corresponded with most of the people involved in the accident that messed up John's leg. As with most incidents recollection is somewhat different by those involved, after all it is from their perspective. I have tried to piece together, as accurately as possible, what happened on that day.
The skydive was a 21-way attempt (20-way box to the right with one stinger). John was the point of the 9-way with Jeff being right row three lock up (#8). Jeff was wearing a side mount helmet camera. Jeff had an on heading opening with the exception of several line-twists, which took him time to clear. On Tom's video from behind, it appears the formation was building fast. Both Jeff and John came back down the right side of the formation. Jeff was lower and behind John, most likely due to Jeff's line twists and possibly different approach styles. I am sure both where in a hurry since it appears they were both late (per Tom's video). They both turned into the formation from the right side.
From that point until impact the facts are a little foggy. The actual collision is not on tape. It was below or out of frame on Tom's video and Jeff's did show it clear either. Some how John's left leg struck Jeff on the left side of his head, slightly from behind. Exactly how this can happen is unclear to me, but it did occur. After the impact, John blacked out. After Jeff shook the "cob webs off", he looked around but saw no one. Likely upon blacking out John went into some brakes, and was behind and slightly above Jeff. Jeff was a little confused but didn't feel the crash was hard, so he thought it was a collision with no major consequences and went into the formation.
When John came around, he headed to the formation calling for help. The formation had completed to row 4 with their lockups on, the number nine slot was plugged. It was evident that no one else saw the collision. John stacked docked on the formation on the right row wing 4 lockup (Jacob ). John communicated to Jacob that he had a broken leg and needed help. This fact startled Jacob some what and he pondered how he could have broke his leg. John and Jacob then went into a plane configuration. Again John communicated that he'd broken his leg and could Jacob help. Jacob told John yes. Jacob's first thoughts were that he had never landed a bi-plane before. Then Jacob heard from other people telling him to drop John, wrong position, etc. (most likely the others were unaware of the situation). Jacob ignored the suggestions but was thinking about if the formation funneled it could get much worse for John. At this point, Jacob became confused - He didn't know what to do. He had never been in a situation like this before or instructed on what to do. Jacob was thinking, listening for suggestions, and looking at the spot and where they were - plenty of altitude. Jacob finally figured he'd fly John home and was about to ask for a drop. But all this reasoning took time.
John was relieved, but passed out shortly after hearing he was going to be helped. John suddenly flew up and back. It is hard to tell from the video, but it looks like the tail of John's canopy deflects. I am almost positive, like all good CRW dawgs, John still had his hands in his toggles and upon passing out his arms relaxed an he went into brakes and was pulled off the formation. Jacob really didn't know what to do. Jacob quickly lost sight of John. Jacob thought about going after him - but figured if he was hurt bad he wouldn't have left the formation. Jacob had no idea that John had just passed out. Jacob decided to stayed put in the formation. John thought he had help all the way to the ground right; but when he came to, he did not see any canopies or anybody. His hands were at his side (out of his controls). John looked down, saw the airport runway and headed in. It took everything John had to stay aware and land. Most of you know the rest of the story. Cathy has kept us well informed on John's condition and recovery. BTW the formation completed to a 20-way.
Lessons to be learned - Collisions can happen but to minimize the possibility look around try to figure out were the other people you are docking on or docking on you are. Every now and then some one is going to have a bad opening that will put them out of echelon sequence. If it means slowing down and having a longer split time because of a traffic problem, that is OK and it can be discussed and corrected on the ground prior to the next jump -- collisions are much more costly on split times.
If someone is injured in the sky, help them out - call "break it down". Whenever anyone hears "break it down", begin as soon as possible breaking it down in an orderly fashion. "Break it down" usually means things are going to get worse if the formation continues. For those in the formation below the "break it down" call, remember gravity still rules. A "break it down" call can be given by anyone, at any time - and should be honored by those around. Yes, knowing the full details about this incident makes it easy to make this call after the fact. But we should always try to think (in general terms) what might happen and what action should be taken, be conservative.
If someone is injured someone should always stay with that person. If your skill level enables you to top dock someone and help them fly their canopy do so (if the person is willing or unconscious). If you feel you do not have the skill level, stay with the person but try and notify as many people that there is an injured skydiver they may be able to help. We need to pass this type of lesson on to the beginners. Inform newcomers to big way CRW of responsibilities and expectations of them. Teach them how to be safe and to look out for the safety of others.
Was the "helmet cam" at fault in the above incident? It is hard to tell if it really limited his vision or not in this case. But I can think of many reasons not to wear one in the formation. Although these new cameras are streamlined they can still pose a snag hazard for the person wearing them (broken necks really hurt). People wearing them tend to film others around them when they are in the formation. This leads to a lapse of concentration on them not flying their canopy when in the formation. Those around the camera tend to "geek" the camera making them do a similar lapse of concentration on their parachutes. Both of those are not healthy for the formation. I am not suggesting outlawing cameras from inside the formation as they can be used as a good tool (at times), but one should check with the organizers about flying it.
Final Note on Moss Point: People have asked me over the past several weeks "Why was Moss Point so cut-a-way crazy"? Yes, we had our share - that weekend 8 of them. One of them was a packing/deployment malfunction but 7 is still a high number. My answer to that is because we challenged people more then in previous camps. We had many new people in wing slots; we had new people with little experience in big ways, and we had some just plain inexperience in CRW. True some of the wing flyers had "some" experience, but they had never been asked to repeatedly dock that particular wing for an entire weekend. Many docks were made hard, and hard docks usually result in wraps. A percentage of those wraps usually result in cut-a-ways. Many people were challenged that weekend, it gave them new experience and hopefully new skills. During my training for big way attempts in the past, I have seen similar "wrapfests" occur. Whenever you put new people in new more challenging slots, the wrap rate
|